Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Migrating to "The Cloud"

It looks like everyone these days is moving to the Cloud, my company included. I wonder if our information really is safe out there and whether or not government agencies are too quick to jump on the bandwagon. NPR has some great discussions and links to cloud computing stories here:
http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2010/07/26/128777743/agencies-migrating-to-e-mail-in-the-cloud

A $35 Tablet For Education?

http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2010/07/27/128800669/indian-government-35-tablet-skeptic
This article discusses the cost of education (an issue near and dear to my heart). In the race for building ever cheaper personal computers, the builders have lost sight of the real issue: creating access to education. Access to a cheap computer is NOT access to education. I have seen this myself firsthand in Brazil, where they now have an internet cafe on every corner where kids spend countless hours updating their online profile, instant messaging and playing games. Has the level and quality of education increased because these kids are on a computer? No.
What ever happened to CONTENT? Will giving a poor kid in India a $35 toy of a laptop have any bearing on whether that kid will get a quality education? No.

"While the cost of the proposed Indian device is the headline grabber, Stager says that making money the focus of any effort like this undercuts the ultimate goal of education:
Children deserve better than to have their future inhibited by price. Going to a funding agency and asking for one of something for every child requires you to pick the right something. It's often impossible to go back to the well when our initial goals were so meager and based on such unimaginative criteria."

I will continue to use Web 2.0 tools

I will most definitely begin taking more advantage of certain tools I’ve found that bring practicality to my life. I don’t think I should use a tool just because it’s the latest thing to do. I will use a tool to the extent that it furthers my personal goals. When I began this class, I only used social networking sites (Facebook, specifically). I now blog, which is an excellent way for me to internalize knowledge by reflecting and putting my own spin on it. I also have begun using Diigo over the past 3 months. I love the way it helps me collect everything I’m reading and working on into one space. The latest tool I’ve used is Wikispaces. The fact that building pages is super easy, made it my #1 choice for my Produsage assignment.
The Wiki contains academic articles, book chapters, and other readings that have been assigned by my professors throughout my MS program. It also contains information on professional and academic associations, as well as a page with over 50 links to useful resources, such as software tutorials, stock photo websites, educational pages, and other resources that might come in handy to an instructional designer.
There is also a page with links to other Wikis created by FSU students and their professors, as well as a page for FSU students to post examples of learning objectives, and other examples of analyses, needs assessments, or other academic papers for the purpose of showcasing their work, requesting input, or sharing lessons learned.
I will definitely consider using a Wiki in my next HPT project, since I consider it an excellent tool for enhancing communication, and creating a unified space for an organization. I will also continue with Diigo. Most importantly, I am actively searching out new tools and ready for what comes ahead.

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

I write myself into being

danah boyd (my favorite blogger: http://www.zephoria.org/thoughts/) discusses “impression management” as a critical social skill that enables us to make meaning out of our interactions with people. Since we are not physically visible to each other in person, we can write ourselves into being by using text, images, audio, and video to create our own digital bodies.
What is the best social networking site for creating my digital body? Orkut would be OK if most of my friends were in Brazil. MySpace would be fine if I was OMG 15 years old! I guess Facebook is the place to go for someone like me.
Check out this article http://www.slate.com/id/2168872/about a Facebook platform that allows the users to customize their pages, just like MySpace users. Does this mean Facebook will turn into MySpace with all those head-exploding designs that only kids can stand to look at? Or does it mean, as the article purports, that Facebook will crush the competition and take over the world?

WikiLeaks Anyone?

When will it be time to say that political activist bloggers have gone too far? I’m not sure that much of the unsuspecting public, which is largely unaware of the way in which bloggers are able to influence the news, are able to differentiate “news” from “agenda pushing”.

danah boyd writes about the four characteristics that fundamentally separate unmediated publics from networked publics (where the blogs are):

1. Persistence: the period of existence of any speech act is extended

2. Searchability: everything is recorded online and through text so the information is easily found.

3. Replicability: “networked public expressions can be copied from one place to another verbatim such that there is no way to distinguish the original from the copy”.

4. Invisible audiences: it is impossible to know who each individual is that may come across our expression in networked publics.

Here are two examples of these four characteristics occurring within a networked public and influencing our entire nation, including our armed forces and our president.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/38413617/ns/technology_and_science-security

Julian Assange has described himself as an "information activist" — get the information out there and let what happens happen, the Australian-born founder of WikiLeaks has said publicly. But it's also been said that Assange rarely sleeps in the same place two nights in a row because of concerns about his own safety.
Assange, 39, started WikiLeaks.org in 2007, describing the site's mission as an "uncensorable system for untraceable mass document leaking." The site now reportedly hosts more than 1 million documents, and there are thousands more to come related to Afghanistan, Assange said Monday in a press conference.

http://theweek.com/article/index/205204/was-shirley-sherrod-framed-by-the-right

The controversy over ousted U.S.D.A. official Shirley Sherrod's comments on race just got more complicated. Sherrod resigned under pressure Tuesday after conservative Web publisher Andrew Breitbart posted a video clip of Sherrod.

It looks like blogs become the news via an automated process that allows for checks and balances only after the facts, and by then it may be too late.

How authorship, copyright and open access impact my desire, ability and willingness to engage in produsage:

I have always been interested in Creative Commons licenses because they allow greater flexibility in sharing work. The information below is taken from http://creativecommons.org/about/licenses.
Note that there are several additional levels of Attribution by, as well as a blend of Attribution by and Share alike.

Attribution
by
You let others copy, distribute, display, and perform your copyrighted work — and derivative works based upon it — but only if they give credit the way you request.

Share Alike
sa
You allow others to distribute derivative works only under a license identical to the license that governs your work.

Non-Commercial
nc

You let others copy, distribute, display, and perform your work — and derivative works based upon it — but for non-commercial purposes only.

No Derivative Works
nd
You let others copy, distribute, display, and perform only verbatim copies of your work, not derivative works based upon it.

I would very much like to create a Wiki where instructional design professionals, myself included, can post links to our work and research papers, etc. There is always the chance that an individual might try to take the credit for work that was not done by him, but this chance exists anyway in our constantly connected universe. Although my first instinct is to put all of my work away for safekeeping so no one can copy me, I do see an advantage in sharing information. Namely, that other people will share their information with me and we can collaborate. Additionally, putting myself “out there” is a way for me to get noticed and possibly generate greater opportunities.

Wednesday, July 21, 2010

How do I judge expertise on the Web?

I’m not always entirely sure how to go about judging expertise on the web. It used to be the case that Wikipedia was not considered a reliable reference source. Now, that we know there are thousands of pairs of eyes who scour through every entry and provide corrections and updates and we understand the editing process, most of us actually find Wikipedia to be more reliable and up-to-date than other more conventional reference sources. This is yet another example of cloudsourcing as an invaluable resource.
Wikipedia aside, I generally defer to an expert source (a professor, academic journal, a professional who is more knowledgeable than me) in order to determine whether or not I should consider a source or person to be an “expert” on any given matter. I often look in texts for references to known works or authors or for affiliations to larger organizations.
More often than not, I am skeptical about the expertise of any resource on the web unless I am somehow able to confirm validity via the processes I just described.

Tuesday, July 20, 2010

Crowdsourcing: an invaluable resource

Jeff Howe, in his blog at wired.com "The Rise of Crowdsourcing" described the incredibly cheap pool of labor now available for research and development. He states, "For the last decade or so, companies have been looking overseas, to India or China, for cheap labor. But now it doesn't matter where the laborers are...as long as they are connected to the network." Granovetter described "the strength of weak ties", which according to Howe are the most efficient networks since they "link to the broadest range of information, knowledge, and experience."
Here is a prime example:
Two undergraduates at Rice University developed a $30 tool to detect anemia in blood samples that does not use electricity. http://shine.yahoo.com/channel/health/salad-spinner-centrifuge-a-cheap-ingenious-health-care-tool-2019637/
The most noteworthy aspect of this tool is that development was basically free! Imagine how much a medical equipment developer would have paid its scientists to research and develop a tool for detecting anemia that does not use electricity. Some other examples of crowdsourcing that take advantage of extremely low or non-existent development costs are Wikipedia, iStockphoto, Youtube, and InnoCentive. Even a child can get in on the action!

Monday, July 19, 2010

Anonymity is not essential to productive user comments

Arianna Huffington, editor-in-chief of the Huffington Post says: "People no longer want to just passively sit back and be served up information. We now engage with news, react to news, and share news. News has become something around which we gather, connect, and converse."

http://www.cnn.com/2010/TECH/web/07/19/commenting.on.news.sites/index.html?hpt=C2

This article deals with issues that journalists and news sites are having with nasty user comments. Online news publishers struggle between granting anonymity, which allows users to post whatever they please (even defamatory or derogatorry comments) without revealing their identity, and moderating comments by requiring contributors to register and/or pay a small fee.

The Wall Street Journal has a commenter who has made inflamatory comments that have gotten her death threats but she states, "The opportunity to post your ideas and beliefs far outweigh a few crazy people."

Bill Adee from the Chicago Tribune suggests tying commenter's posts to their online social media profiles. While this would certainly reign in a lot of the trash talk, is it going to encourage the type of comments that drive people to the news site? I'm not sure what to think...

Wednesday, July 14, 2010

Millennials are always on!

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/38165531/ns/technology_and_science-tech_and_gadgets/

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/35545420/ns/technology_and_science-wireless

I came across these articles and it reminded me of the dilemmas my husband and I face every day with our teenagers. Can't they stop texting for 5 minutes? Do they really have to constantly post updates to Facebook or MySpace?
After reading "Leisure is Hard Work" by Drotner, I might have to rethink my approach. She writes: "Young people's digital practices promote the formation of competencies that are absolutely vital to their future, in an economic, social, and cultural sense. Adults need to recognize the validity of these practices in the spirit of democratic participation, and acknowledge young people's right to havev a voice and to be heard."

Use of a corporate wiki: less wasted resources

I recently completed a consulting project for a multi-national firm that had serious communication issues. Everyone seemed to be pushing their own agenda and not listening to each other. A big problem this company faced was meaningless meetings in which everyone pretended to listen but nothing was actually accomplished.
Here is an example of what would actually happen:
The production department heads from the US, Spain, and China would have a meeting scheduled 3 weeks in advance. In preparation for the “big” meeting, the US production team would have many “small” meetings (meetings to prepare for meetings). During the 3-week period, different production supervisors and managers would prepare lengthy reports and PowerPoint presentations to circulate via email in advance of the small meetings. Note that these PP presentations were created in a way that defied logic. It was not unusual to see a 36-slide presentation with each slide containing 6 paragraphs of fine-print text!
Of course, no one would actually read the reports and PP presentations since there were so many and they were so UN-user-friendly, so no one would actually know what the other participants wanted to discuss at the pre-meeting. Everyone would then bring their own agendas to argue at the meeting and nothing much would be accomplished. Finally, when the “big” meeting came, it was a reenactment of the same confusion, magnified tenfold.
A collaborative wiki for each department would have gone a long way towards creating a common understanding and ensuring that less time and resources were wasted. Of course there are other simple things that professionals should know, such as how to create an effective presentation. In the absence of this, there should be a pre-determined format for all reports (ie: no longer than 2 pages, with graphs showing specific outputs, etc).
In the case of this corporate wiki, it would be very important to do a thorough analysis to determine what the needs and desired results of the wiki are in order to create it in such a way that it suits participant’s needs, thus providing incentives and motivation for incorporating it into corporate practices.

I am not a vaguebooker!

Dr. Dennen recently commented on “vaguebookers”. You know, the attention seekers who post things like:
Joice…
Is feeling happy about her conversation
Thinks it’s unfair
Is making big plans

This actually really irritates me. I’m not sure if it’s because I’m “too old” for this “constant connection” thing. I honestly don’t think anyone cares that much about the minutia of anyone else’s life, regardless of the headline grabbing updates people post. Maybe this is the core difference between a Facebook user who is 30 and one who is 15. We have higher standards regarding news that we consider worthy of sharing or maybe we have other outlets for self-expression, which make the attention-grabbing headlines unnecessary.

Wednesday, July 7, 2010

OMG! I love Diigo!

I used Diigo last semester as part of a class assignment. This time around, I plan to use Diigo to organize my library. I read so many things online and have often saved important URLs using the functions provided by my web browser. Diigo is by far the best cloud-based information management tool I have found so far. On any website I access, I can highlight text, add a sticky note, bookmark, or make a comment. Whenever I do this, the text is added to my library. My library can be accessed from ANY computer or phone that has internet so I can begin reading something on my PC at work, mark it, and then finish reading it from my PC at home. All notes or highlights I make remain on the pages in my library. I can categorize or organize texts by tags. I can also take pictures (snapshots) of entire pages.
Not only can Diigo be used for group collaboration, it can also be used as a personal learning resource and a tool for organizing everything. The fact that it is available on the cloud means I don’t even have to carry my personal laptop around. I can work and read from any PC in the world.

http://www.diigo.com/

Am I a produser?

Produsage refers to simultaneous production and usage, more commonly known as user-led content creation. While it has generally been the case that producers of media are separate from users of media, Web 2.0 tools such as social networking, knowledge management, citizen journalism, colaborative filtering, and open source software development have created a landscape of user-led content, changing the balance of power from producers to users and creating a new class of produsers.

We have seen numerous examples of changes in public perception due to new forms of sharing news and reacting to opposition. In places like Iran, group communication becomes necessary for coordinating public action by the opposition. Why else would the government try to block social networking and internet access outside the country? Shirky (2008) states "Whenever you improve a group's ability to communicate internally, you change the things it is capable of." This, I believe is the biggest benefit of produsage - the ability to form groups in ways not previously possible.

As a produser, I am less producer than user because I don't dedicate the time necessary for this. As it becomes financially interesting or as I find a cause or other reason to become more active, I can see myself producing more.

Prince Declares the Internet "Dead"

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/38109497/ns/38104697

Bruns, in his paper on Produsage refers to "'Generation C', whose creative engagement in content development will lead to a casual collapse of ... formal requirements and laws modern societies have held dear - including a good part of the traditional content production industries." He goes on to say, "this is already evident in the crises experienced by industries as diverse as software, journalism, music...each of which have struggled to hold on to existing markets while finding it difficult to attract new consumers."
Maybe this is why Prince has decided to declare the internet's demise. The music industry (and Prince) has struggled tremendously with file sharing, remixing, etc. Given that the internet has created the foundation for many of the threats to his income, what better way to fight this phenomena than to declare the internet to be "dead"? Prince, wishing the internet would just magically disappear so you could go back to the good old days when the music industry controlled all production and distribution won't solve anything. All jokes aside, the only thing disappearing is you.

Thursday, July 1, 2010

Reconsidering Blogs

As a busy person, I don’t really have (or take) much time to read or follow blogs. I read a blog here or there if someone points me to it (especially if it is a class assignment). I actually think blogs are an excellent solution for sharing best practices and for communication within an organization. In this instance you almost have a captive audience because there are built-in incentives for reading or contributing to the blog. However, bloggers that have an audience of, say, 5 or 12 readers have always been a mystery to me. Why would someone continue to write a blog if almost no one is reading it? The answer, according to Shirky is that the blogger never intended to write for a large audience. He or she just wants to communicate, regardless of the number of readers. The blog could then be considered a conversation in a small group, just like a three-way phone call. Before reading Shirky I considered a blog with few followers to be less successful than a blog with many followers. My view has changed somewhat regarding this. Fame and success are not necessarily equal. A blogger might not desire to become famous and have a million followers. Rather, a blogger may simply want to express something to his peers, family, or friends. This means that the capacity for reciprocal communication that blogging affords is enough in itself to justify the blog. I guess I’ll feel like less of a loser if only three people are reading this blog.

Wednesday, June 30, 2010

What I want, what I really, really, want

What I want from this blog is to gain fluency in Web 2.0 so that I can easily use it to accomplish the projects and tasks that I set out to complete. I don’t just want to use Web 2.0 for the sake of using it, just as some organizations incorporate technology in order to appear relevant, regardless of whether or not the technology they chose is relevant to their needs. I want to be fluent enough in Web 2.0 that I can pick and choose from among tools in order to find the function that best suits my purpose.
As an HPT practitioner, I hope to use these tools to improve performance by creating communities, sharing information, and collaborating. I don’t want to be so stumped by the technology that I get stuck on it and lose sight of the goal. I also want to know enough about Web 2.0 to be able to create easy to use resources for individuals who may not yet be avid users.
As I write this, I am touch-typing. This means that I can write as fast as I think, without stopping to look for the keys on the keyboard. My train of thought is not interrupted by my lack of keyboard fluency. In much the same way, I want to be fluent in at least some Web 2.0 technologies so that I can use them intuitively. This will change my relationship from barely being a Web 2.0 follower, to not imagining how I lived or worked without these tools.

Am I a Web 2.0 leader or follower?

I think I would have to say that up until now, I have been a distant follower/user of Web 2.0 technologies. I have often accessed other people’s blogs, Wikipedia, shared work in a team through Google docs, posted to FSU BB, posted pictures on Facebook, etc. I’ve used these technologies as tools for work or study-related purposes, but only as much as was absolutely necessary for “survival”.
I generally enjoy using and learning new tools and IT is indispensible for the work I do, so why am I not a leader or at least a very close follower? I think there are several reasons for this:
1) I’m very busy working, raising a family, and carrying a full class load, so I only use tools as they come into my daily activities or as they are introduced by someone else in order to complete a specific task. I don’t go out of my way to find or use new Web 2.0 technologies because I’m too busy.
2) There is no specific driving force compelling me to incorporate more Web 2.0 into my life. In the case of the fashion student documenting the Thai coup, or in the case of the woman who lost her phone in NYC, they had an underlying reason for their pursuit. If I had an urgent message to get across or if my job required me to develop a Web 2.0 resource, I would most likely be one of the individuals at the forefront of social media tool usage.

When I first read the class assignments, I was a little worried about producing my very own resource using Web 2.0 because I don’t feel up to the task. On the other hand, this is precisely the opportunity I need to become an avid user and to be able to take full advantage of the group forming capabilities that Web 2.0 offers.